This post is a call to arms.
Seriously.
I read a study today that first saddened, then enraged, then inspired me. I hope it will do the same for you. The study was published by The Council of the Great City Schools, a consortium of urban public school systems from around the country. The subject: academic underachievement among black males. If you are the parent of a young black male, YOU MUST READ the recently published Call for Change study. If you are not the parent of a young black male but know someone who is, YOU MUST READ this study and pass it along to someone else. Oh, and if you are the parent or know the parent of a young black female, you are not off the hook. YOU MUST READ this study because what it says about our daughters isn't any more promising. Put simply, the word CRISIS is now an understatement.
Some context...
Yes, we've all heard the hoopla in recent weeks surrounding the new Bill Gates backed Waiting for Superman documentary. You know the one that everyone from Oprah, to President Obama, has been touting as a "call to action" for our country? The one that laments the fact that U.S. students are now ranked a lowly 25th in math among 30 of the world's developed countries. The one that points out the shocking statistic that by fourth grade, 68% of public school students scored below a proficient reading level in 2009. The one that blames the public school bureaucracy for pretty much everything. Well, if you're a black parent and you thought things were bad, perhaps you should sit down. It gets MUCH worse.
First let's look in the MIRROR:
- In 2009, only 11% of black boys in 4th grade performed at or above PROFICIENT levels in reading. (Students attended public schools in cities with populations of 250,000 or more)
- In my hometown of Cleveland, OH, only 3% --That's right--THREE measly PERCENT of 4th grade black males scored at or above proficient levels. UGHHHHHHHH!
- In 2009, black male 4th graders NOT eligible for free or reduced priced lunch (based on income) had reading and mathematics scores similar to or lower than white males who WERE eligible for free or reduced priced lunch (based on income). About 21% in each group performed at or above proficient levels.
- By 8th grade, the achievement gap between this same group widened to six points in favor of white males.
That's pretty bad, but here's the real slap in the face. Brace yourself and read on:
- In 2009, black males WITHOUT disabilities performed worse than white males WITH disabilities! Only 13% of non-disabled black male 4th graders compared to 17% of disabled white male 4th graders performed at or above proficient levels in reading.
I read this study today, all 106 pages of it. And I was ready. With each dismal statistic, my will to be part of the solution grew stronger. But when I read the "Plan of Action and Recommendations" conclusion, I realized (with anger) that the study authors in their "scholarly wisdom" had once again let me and every other black parent off the hook. Not one of the recommendations asks black parents to do ANYTHING differently (much like the Wait for Superman, blame the system approach). The word, "parent", isn't even mentioned. That is sickening. Our babies are failing at epidemic rates, and we have no obligation to change the outcome? Ridiculous.
Let's Do Something About It.
Black parents, we need to pick up the mirror and face the fact that the blame for our children's failure starts and ends with us. Not the school. Not white racism. Not cultural bias. US! We need to take ownership of success of our next generation like our ancestors did and our counterparts in other races still do. Realize that the schools can't and shouldn't have to do it all.
I am fired up and ready to start a movement of black parents ready to return our children to excellence. Our black boys are too precious to leave in the hands of anyone else. If you're ready to take some responsibility, please jump in.
Dear Reader, I crave your thoughts and prayers on this issue. It has been near to my heart since the birth of my first son and for some time I have felt that God has a purpose for me that includes helping black boys to achieve. I am still seeking God for exactly what this purpose looks like, but I know that it starts with raising our two sons to be high achieving, Godly, men of character.
Stay tuned, this is a call to arms!!
P.S. Don't forget to read the study for yourself to fully understand the populations of students examined- there are some significant nuances that I didn't get into here. Also, the first nine pages are an Executive Summary that lays out the parameters of the data examined and includes every data point separated by bullets. The rest of the study is mostly graphs illustrating the data.
Here Here and welcome to the fight!
ReplyDeleteIt's hard to study parents because the nature of the data on parents is not standardized beyond income and those types of demographic data, but your point is very well taken. Researchers can't really say what they can't empirically show (in those graphs you mention).
I haven't read this particular study yet but will have to put it on the list! Black boys have been the children "left furthest behind" for as long as I can remember. Also parenting is not an "earned" right. You don't need a license or any type of qualifications and all the training is "on the job". At best you follow models you have experienced or see (until you realize that only works so far).
Expectations has been a big issue in the literature, where black boys are just not expected to do well, or when they don't it's not so "alarming". Then if that is the "culture" and the institutions are blamed then the cycle continues. Raise the Bar. Expect more and perhaps they will rise to the occasion. They are kids, they don't know any better so an early high bar that never gets lowered might be a way that parents can help. Make sure that the bar is set high both inside school and outside of school.
Many teachers even will content that MOST learning happens outside of the school walls not inside the school walls (mostly teaching going on then). The magic happens after he last bell and before the first bell the next day.
I applaud your "call to arms" and hope you find your way to leading the next movement!!!
Go girl go!
I really enjoyed your post! You are so right... never thought about how easy the Tea Party formed and how we too as parents can and should band together to help our young boys. So many want to turn their heads and say it is not our problem but ultimately this affects us all in different ways. I knew the achievement gap is still a problem but the stats you mentioned are sad. I too am starting with our young son but have open arms and ears to help others that I can reach. I wish we could band together like we did when we had the Million Man and Women March years ago. Thanks for bringing this to our attentions.
ReplyDelete@mrthorn10 and Melissa: Thanks for the comments. I have been working "offline" to research this problem and speak with other concerned parents about possible steps forward. I truly believe that the future of our race is at stake. Please read the study if you haven't already. I'd love to hear your thoughts.
ReplyDelete